Case Study 3: “Scientific Article and Statistical Manipulation” (High Complexity)
Scenario:
A graduate student is writing a sociology research paper. In the article, he uses survey data but deliberately omits data that weakens the overall conclusion. He adjusts the graph scale to emphasize a positive trend. In the conclusion section, he claims a causal relationship without statistical evidence.
Tasks:
1. Identify the actions that represent data manipulation.
● Why is it unethical to exclude part of the sample without explanation?
2. Distinguish between correlation and causation.
● Provide an example where correlation does not imply causation.
● How can one test for a causal relationship?
3. Explain how to ethically present research findings.
● What should be included in explanations of statistical data?
● How should limitations and confidence intervals be reported?
4. Edit the conclusion paragraph to make it scientifically sound and ethically valid.
5. Propose recommendations to prevent manipulations in future research.
Background Colour
Font Face
Font Kerning
Font Size
Image Visibility
Letter Spacing
Line Height
Text Colour